Does timing the market matter as much as just being invested? It’s a question every investor has asked at some point. The idea of buying low and selling high is tempting but how realistic is it? What if there’s a simpler, more reliable way to get to increase your stock portfolio worth?
In this post, I’ll tell the story of three investors: Perfect Timing Paul, Terrible Timing Tina and Steady Sam. Each has a different approach to investing but only one strategy will lead to long term success. Their story will show you why the buy and hold strategy, dollar cost averaging – investing the same amount regularly – and solid investing principles are the keys to increase the value of your stock portfolio.
If you’re a long term investor looking for stable returns the message is clear: you don’t have to predict the highs and lows to succeed. Just be steady and disciplined and you’ll grow your portfolio and reduce stress and risk.
Join me as I tell this story and discover the lessons that fit with the principles of fundamental analysis and long term growth. Whether you’re new to investing or experienced, these will remind you why patience and consistency wins.
Long Term Investing
Long term investing is a strategy of holding onto investments for an extended period, typically five years or more. This approach helps investors ride out the market fluctuations and benefit from compounding. By taking a long term view, investors can reduce their exposure to market volatility and increase their chances of achieving their financial goals.
What is Long Term Investing?
Long term investing is a mindset that prioritizes steady, consistent growth over short term gains. It’s about making informed investment decisions based on a deep understanding of the financial markets and a clear view of your financial goals. Long term investors build wealth over time not try to time the market or make quick profits.
The Three Investors
Three friends, each with a different approach to investing in the stock market. First there’s Perfect Timing Paul who seems to have super powers. He always buys at the bottom of the market, he perfectly times every investment. Then there’s Terrible Timing Tina who has the worst luck. She always buys at the top of the market just before it crashes. Finally there’s Steady Sam who takes a disciplined approach. Sam invests the same amount of money at regular intervals, no matter what the market is doing – this is called dollar cost averaging.
At first, you’d bet on Paul’s perfect timing to deliver the best returns. (Spoiler: He does come out on top but the difference might surprise you!) After all buying at the bottom should make him the richest. When it comes to Tina, she seems cursed with her habit of buying at the worst possible times. But Sam’s steady, consistent investing may surprise you. By sticking to his plan Sam takes advantage of the market fluctuations, buying more when prices are low and less when they’re high.
In this story you’ll see why timing the market isn’t as important as just being invested for the long term. The lesson? A disciplined approach beats good or bad luck in the financial world.
Perfect Timing Paul: The Myth of Market Timing
Paul seems like the super lucky investor. He always buys stocks at their lowest prices just before the market starts to rise. His strategy sounds unbeatable – buying at the bottom means maximum profits when prices go up. But here’s the catch: predicting the bottom of the market with perfect accuracy is impossible. Even the great Warren Buffett avoids trying to time the market, he knows how unpredictable it is.
Waiting for the “perfect moment” to invest is risky. Many investors who try this end up sitting on the sidelines missing out on market growth while they wait for prices to drop. Market trends are influenced by so many factors – economic conditions, company performance, investor behaviour. No one, not even the fund managers, can consistently predict when stock prices will hit rock bottom. As a matter of fact, 84.71% of US funds underperformed the S&P 500 on a 10 years period.
Instead of chasing perfection, successful long term investors focus on a disciplined approach. They stay invested through market cycles and benefit from long term growth. By investing regularly, no matter what the market is doing, they avoid the stress of market timing and build wealth steadily. Remember it’s not about buying at the perfect time – it’s about being invested for the long term. This approach which includes long term investing strategies means your portfolio will grow over time even through market fluctuations.
Terrible Timing Tina: The Cost of Bad Luck
Terrible Timing Tina seems to have the worst luck in the financial world. Every time she decides to invest she buys at the market’s highest point – just before a big drop. For many investors this would be a nightmare. But Tina has one advantage, she stays invested! Despite her terrible timing she never pulls her money out of the market. Instead she holds onto her stocks through every market swing.
Over time this disciplined approach pays off. Why? Because the stock market, despite its ups and downs, generally trends upwards in the long term. By staying the course Tina benefits from compounding growth – where her gains generate more gains. Even when stock prices drop she doesn’t panic sell, she lets her investments recover and grow.
Tina’s story shows that even the worst timing can be overcome with patience and consistency. Market volatility and fluctuations are part of investing but by focusing on long term goals and being invested Tina makes money over time. Her story shows why successful long term investors prioritise their investment horizon over short term market conditions. It’s a lesson that individual investors can apply to retirement accounts, diversified portfolios and beyond to achieve long term investing success.
Steady Sam: Dollar Cost Averaging
Steady Sam’s approach to investing is simple but effective: he invests a fixed amount of money at the beginning of each month regardless of what the market is doing. This is dollar cost averaging. He avoids the stress of trying to time the market. Instead of worrying about whether prices are high or low he sticks to his plan and lets the strategy work over time.
One of the biggest benefits of dollar cost averaging is it reduces emotional decision making. Many investors panic during market crashes or get too excited during market booms and make poor decisions. Sam avoids these traps by being consistent. He also benefits from market volatility, buying more shares when prices are low and fewer shares when prices are high which reduces his overall cost per share.
This disciplined approach makes long term investing more accessible for individual investors. Sam doesn’t have to guess the right time to invest which even the best professionals struggle to do. Over a longer period this strategy helps him grow his ETF investment portfolio steadily. By focusing on his financial goals and ignoring market swings Sam builds wealth and achieves long term success.
Results: A Visual
Let’s see how Perfect Timing Paul, Terrible Timing Tina, and Steady Sam performed after 25 years (from Jan 2000 to Dec 2024). Each invested $500 per month, totaling $150,000 into the S&P 500 Total Return index.
- Perfect Timing Paul invested at the absolute market low every month. His portfolio grew to $785,426.86, the highest result. But let’s be real: predicting market bottoms consistently is nearly impossible for any investor.
- Terrible Timing Tina invested at the market’s peak every month. Despite her unfortunate timing, she still ended with $736,561.78. Her results show that staying invested pays off, as long-term market growth works in your favor, even with bad timing.
- Steady Sam followed the dollar-cost averaging (DCA) strategy, investing the same amount each month regardless of market conditions. His portfolio reached $758,567.21, just slightly behind Paul but ahead of Tina. By sticking to a consistent plan, Sam took advantage from market volatility without needing to time the market perfectly.
The takeaway? Both Tina and Sam prove that being invested is far better than sitting on the sidelines. And for most investors, dollar-cost averaging like Sam offers a reliable path to long-term success, even in unpredictable markets.
Plus, over 25 years, the difference between the best-performing portfolio (Paul’s) and the worst-performing portfolio (Tina’s) is just around 6%, a negligible gap over such a long period. Timing the market may seem attractive, but time in the market remains the true winner.
If you want to see the figures and how I computed the PTF value of our 3 investors, you can download the excel file in which I did all my analysis, click here!
Thanks for reading my article. More info about the author here
